Don't make titles roll up just because the 245 and 246 match
Since 2 different books with the same title (i.e. 12 days of Christmas) are likely to have identical 245 and 246 fields, require additional matches in order to roll up the titles, such as ISBN, publisher, publication date, etc.
Sarah Peterson
shared this idea
Nothing would rollup if we matched on ISBN. Publication date likewise would prevent every edition of Jane Eyre from rolling up. Vega is a work level catalog and will not make changes that would revert it to a bibliographic record level catalog. Please note that we also do not currently match on 246.
There are plans for cataloger permissions to manage rollup problems that I hope will meet your needs in the future.
-
Sarah Peterson
commented
The current proposed workaround by Innovative is to incorrectly catalog one of the items so they don't match. This is not an acceptable solution - requiring some sort of additional matching is needed as many books are published that have the same title as other completely different books.